: Jan Müller
: Mechanisms of Trust News Media in Democratic and Authoritarian Regimes
: Campus Verlag
: 9783593419831
: 1
: CHF 36.30
:
: Vergleichende und internationale Politikwissenschaft
: English
: 225
: Wasserzeichen/DRM
: PC/MAC/eReader/Tablet
: PDF
Das Vertrauen in die Institutionen des demokratischen Staates sinkt. Die Nachrichtenmedien werden von dieser Entwicklung nicht verschont. In einer länderübergreifenden Analyse kommt Jan Müller zu dem überraschenden Ergebnis, dass zwar in westlichen Demokratien ein ausgeprägter Vertrauensverlust in die Medien zu verzeichnen ist, Nachrichtenmedien in autoritären Regimen dagegen von der Bevölkerung als wesentlich glaubwürdiger eingeschätzt werden. Dieser Befund erklärt sich mit dem sogenannten emanzipativen Wertewandel: Je höher die Bildungsressourcen eines Volkes sind, desto ausgeprägter ist das Maß der kritischen Distanzierung von staatlichen und politischen Institutionen.

Jan Müller arbeitet am Zentrum für Demokratieforschung an der Universität Lüneburg.
1. Introduction

Trust in the institutions of democracy has been extensively studied in the past (see Catterberg/Moreno 2005; Dogan 2005; Levi/Stoker 2000 for an overview). Much of the research was prompted by the fear that increasingly skeptical attitudes towards political institutions in democratic countries could undermine the stability of democratic systems. The study of political trust is, however, complicated by different levels of political support. It is often not obvious whether questions that pertain to political trust relate to the political system in general, the regime in power, or to specific politicians. Trust in the news media has received less attention. This is astonishing since the news media has a central role in democratic systems: it should keep the audience informed about policies and politicians and thereby enable citizens to cast an informed vote or to engage in political action. In authoritarian regimes, the news media are equally important because they spread a shared ideology that aims at legitimizing the regime in power. It is questionable whether or not the news media could perform such a function in the absence of the audience's trust in the news media.

Most studies on trust in political institutions are limited to Western democracies. While a number of studies address trust in institutions in non-Western democratic and authoritarian contexts (Pharr 1997; Inoguchi 2002; Kim et al. 2002; Kabashima et al. 2000; Chen/Shi 2001; Mish-ler/Rose 2005; Wang 2005; Kim 2005; Shlapentokh 2006; Lianjiang 2004), levels of trust in institutions in democratic and authoritarian countries are rarely compared. However, such a comparison might be instructive because levels of trust in the news media are often higher in authoritarian countries (figure 1.1).

High levels of trust in the news media are obviously not necessarily conducive to democratization. High levels of trust in authoritarian regimes are not restricted to the news media. Levels of trust in government and parliament are equally high in authoritarian regimes (see figure 1.2 for levels of trust in government) This study strives to find factors that explain these developments and explore their consequences: why is there a loss of trust in the news media in Western democracies compared to some authoritarian regimes? What are the dynamics of trust in the news media over time in Western democ-racies? What are the consequences of different levels of trust? Is low trust in the news media in Western democracies a reason to worry, or is the level of distrust healthy? What is actually meant when citizens answer survey questions referring to trust or confidence in the news media?

The present chapter deals with explanations given in the scientific liter-ature. The following chapters then review these explanations in light of theories of the public sphere. The concept of trust is related to market-oriented, deliberative, and critical theories of the public sphere. There is no well-developed theoretical framework that embeds trust in a theory of the public sphere. Therefore, the aim is to arrive at a more thorough understanding of the notion of trust in the context of the news media, to develop a theoretical framework that covers the role of trust in different types of public spheres, and to generate a set of hypotheses that can be empirically tested. This study argues that trust in the news media refers to the expectation of the audience that the news media can be belie

Table of Content6
1. Introduction10
1.1 Trust in Democratic Institutions13
1.1.1 Levels of Trust13
1.1.2 Measuring Trust16
1.1.3 Influences on Trust17
1.1.4 Impact of Trust19
1.1.5 Trust and Institutions20
1.1.6 Summary21
1.2 Trust in the News Media22
1.2.1 Why Study Trust in the News Media?22
1.2.2 Source Credibility23
1.2.3 Channel Credibility24
1.2.4 Explanations for Different Levels of Trust in the News Media26
1.2.5 News Media Skepticism and Media Malaise26
1.2.6 Emancipative Value Change31
1.3 Summary33
Part 1: Theoretical Framework38
2. Trust40
2.1 Defining Trust41
2.2 Reducing Complexity42
2.3 A Rational-Choice Notion of Trust46
2.4 Cues for Trustworthiness52
2.5 Trust and Modernity54
2.6 A Decrease in Familiarity59
3. Trust in the News Media63
3.1 Market-Oriented Theory of the Public Sphere65
3.1.1 Low Trust as Market Failure68
3.1.2 Low Trust as Audience Failure69
3.1.3 Societal Differentiation and Trust71
3.2 Deliberative Theory of the Public Sphere72
3.2.1 Deliberation and News Media76
3.2.2 Deliberative Public Sphere and Trust82
3.2.3 Explaining a Loss of Trust84
3.3 Critical Theory of the Public Sphere85
3.3.1 Cultural Hegemony87
3.3.2 Critical Theory of the Public Sphere and Trust90
4. Summary and Hypotheses92
4.1 Trust and the Market-Oriented Theory of the Public Sphere94
4.2 Trust and the Deliberative Theory of the Public Sphere96
4.3 Trust and the Critical Theory of the Public Sphere97
Part 2: Analysis and Findings100
5. Measuring Trust in the News Media102
5.1 Operationalizing Trust in the News Media103
5.2 Assessing Trust104
5.3 Is the Loss of Trust in Democratic Countries a Result of Survey Research Bias?111
5.4 Summary112
6. Trust in the News Media over Timeand across Countries113
6.1 Trust in the Printed Press in Western Europe, Canada and the USA114
6.2 Trust in the Printed Press, Television and Radio in Western Europe118
6.3 Trust in the News Media in the USA124
6.4 Trust in the News Media in Countries with Democratic and Authoritarian Regimes128
6.5 Summary131
7. Trust and Emancipative Values135
7.1 Individual-Level Predictors of Trust in the News Media135
7.2 The Operationalization of Emancipative Value Change137
7.2.1 Secular-Rational and Self-Expression Values137
7.2.2 General Factor Structure141
7.2.3 Emancipative Values143
7.2.4 Measurement Invariance across Countries145
7.3 Emancipative Values and Trust in the News Media146
7.4 Trust in Commercial-, Public Service-, and User-Generated News Media154
7.4.1 Trust in Public Service Television in the EU155
7.4.2 Emancipative Value Change and Trust in Online Forums and Blogs157
7.5 Summary160
8. Trust and the Processing of Information161
8.1 The Elaborative Processing of Political Information164
8.2 Need-for-Cognition and Surveillance Gratification168
8.3 Trust and Diversity of the News Media175
8.4 Summary176
9. Consequences of Trust180
9.1 Political Knowledge and Political Action180
9.2 Knowledge of the European Union and the Frequency of Discussing Political Matters192
9.3 Summary195
10. Conclusions197
10.1 Summary of the Findings197
10.2 Dynamics of Trust in the News Media200
10.3 Trust and Institutions202
10.4 Public Sphere and Democracy204
10.5 The (Ir)relevance of Trust in the News Media204
References206
Index224